The Detroit Tigers' season ended in heart-wrenching fashion, leaving fans and players alike with a sense of what-if. But amidst the disappointment, one decision by manager A.J. Hinch has sparked intense debate.
The Controversial Call: Pulling Tarik Skubal
In a thrilling 15-inning battle against the Seattle Mariners, Hinch made a bold move, removing ace pitcher Tarik Skubal after just six dominant innings. Skubal, a true force on the mound, had the Mariners reeling, striking out an incredible 13 batters and setting October records.
But here's where it gets controversial: Skubal was pulled despite his incredible performance, and the Mariners seized the opportunity, tying the game in the seventh.
Hinch defended his decision, stating, "He gave us everything he could." He explained that Skubal's emotional state and physical endurance were factors, indicating that the pitcher had reached his limit.
The Mariners' strategy of working deep counts paid off, pushing Skubal's pitch count to 99 by the end of the sixth. Hinch saw the signs of fatigue and made the call, believing it was an "easy decision."
However, the question remains: Could the Tigers have won if Skubal had stayed in?
And this is the part most people miss: Skubal had consistently pitched beyond seven innings in his previous postseason starts.
Despite the Tigers' valiant effort, with the bullpen holding strong for nine additional innings, the loss stings.
Hinch, though, stands by his decision, accepting the defeat as a part of the game.
"It was an incredible loss for us, but I tip my cap to the Mariners. They earned it, and it was an epic game," he said.
The Seattle Mariners now advance to the ALCS, a testament to their resilience and skill.
So, what do you think? Was Hinch's decision justified, or did it cost the Tigers a shot at glory? Let's discuss in the comments and share our thoughts on this controversial call!
